ENG 333: Oral Report Scorecard

Your Name:              _____________________________________

Student You’re Evaluating:              _____________________________________

Below, please indicate how well the student did on a scale of 0-3 (0=inadequate; 1=needs improvement; 2=good; 3=very good)

1.     Argument was stated clearly:  

2.     Argument was a contestable claim:

3.     Argument was sufficiently narrow to present in 10-15 minutes:

4.     Argument was supported with specific evidence (i.e., reference to specific places in a text), the language of which was given some close attention:

5.     Discussion questions were clear and thoughtful (even if no one responded):

6.     Presenter was clear and organized.  He or she seemed to have practiced:

7.     Report was neither too long nor too short:

8.     Overall, the oral report was:

Total points: